| Verfasser | Thema |
|---|
ad79
Nachrichten: 792
Registriert:
September 2007
|
|
|
tank commander
Nachrichten: 2551
Registriert:
October 2004
|
|
|
ad79
Nachrichten: 792
Registriert:
September 2007
|
|
Re:Breakthrough at Mortain in CB2. How do we record the score in this scenario.
|
Thu, 05 January 2012 21:24
 
|
 |
You describe the problems of how to record the score online correctly and I am aware of that.
But we have the same problem when scoring for the campaign.
Can the Germans ONLY get 5 medals in this scenario?
Stig Morten
|
|
|
tank commander
Nachrichten: 2551
Registriert:
October 2004
|
|
Re:Breakthrough at Mortain in CB2. How do we record the score in this scenario.
|
Thu, 05 January 2012 22:22
|
|
| ad79 wrote on Thu, 05 January 2012 15:24 |
You describe the problems of how to record the score online correctly and I am aware of that.
But we have the same problem when scoring for the campaign.
Can the Germans ONLY get 5 medals in this scenario?
Stig Morten
|
Ah, I am sorry - I missed that part. For the Campaign I would count the units killed and the medals captured by the Germans. It seems logical to do it this way for scoring purposes.
|
|
|
Almilcar
Nachrichten: 926
Registriert:
November 2011
|
|
Re:Breakthrough at Mortain in CB2. How do we record the score in this scenario.
|
Fri, 28 December 2012 09:49
|
|
| tank commander wrote on Thu, 05 January 2012 02:33 |
Please note that if you only report 5 as the winning score for the Germans and the allies got 6 kills or more then you German win will be recorded as a loss in your service record.
This seems to be standard in scenarios with victory conditions like this.
So , if the Germans win (by capturing the needed 5 OMs), I would just score it 12 German to whatever the Allies scored. in this case, players would then be aware that the Germans got the 5.
If players report a German win with a 5-4 score when the allies actually killed more than 4 units, then the avg allied score in thsi scenario is thrown off and without an aar, players are given a flase impression on how well one side or the other does.
If the Germans lose, record the Allied kills against the number of objectives the Germans captured.
|
Hello, and sorry for bumping this again.
I only see a problem with this scenario and the scoring for the campaign.
If Germans do count the medals gained in the game, plus the units killed, they get a double benefit since in the Objective Track for the Axis they get additional points.
For instance, let's suppose that the Axis player was able to get 4 objectives out of 7 and he killed 7 units.
His final score would be 11 points, but he will get 2 additional points as per the Objective Track.
The situation gets worse if the German managed to capture the 5 permanent objectives. He will score 12 points for the scenario, plus 3 additional points as per the Objective Track.
This scoring system may drastically unbalance the whole campaign, since the Axis can gain for a single scenario up to 15 points.
What are your thoughts?
|
|
|
Sgt Storm
Nachrichten: 930
Registriert:
December 2006
|
|
Re:Breakthrough at Mortain in CB2. How do we record the score in this scenario.
|
Wed, 02 January 2013 17:57
|
|
| Almilcar wrote on Fri, 28 December 2012 03:49 |
| tank commander wrote on Thu, 05 January 2012 02:33 |
Please note that if you only report 5 as the winning score for the Germans and the allies got 6 kills or more then you German win will be recorded as a loss in your service record.
This seems to be standard in scenarios with victory conditions like this.
So , if the Germans win (by capturing the needed 5 OMs), I would just score it 12 German to whatever the Allies scored. in this case, players would then be aware that the Germans got the 5.
If players report a German win with a 5-4 score when the allies actually killed more than 4 units, then the avg allied score in thsi scenario is thrown off and without an aar, players are given a flase impression on how well one side or the other does.
If the Germans lose, record the Allied kills against the number of objectives the Germans captured.
|
Hello, and sorry for bumping this again.
I only see a problem with this scenario and the scoring for the campaign.
If Germans do count the medals gained in the game, plus the units killed, they get a double benefit since in the Objective Track for the Axis they get additional points.
For instance, let's suppose that the Axis player was able to get 4 objectives out of 7 and he killed 7 units.
His final score would be 11 points, but he will get 2 additional points as per the Objective Track.
The situation gets worse if the German managed to capture the 5 permanent objectives. He will score 12 points for the scenario, plus 3 additional points as per the Objective Track.
This scoring system may drastically unbalance the whole campaign, since the Axis can gain for a single scenario up to 15 points.
What are your thoughts?
|
I'm sure we've had this discussion before about this or another similar scenario.
I would score 12 for the Germans if they win.
|
|
|
