Zug um Zug New York Zug um Zug New York

Forum

Suche
Ticket to Ride » T2R Competitive Play - English » Tiebreaker rules in NC
Anzeigen: Heutige Nachrichten 
  
AuthorThread
onyx puffin LOL
Senior Member

Nachrichten: 1684
Registriert:
January 2005
Tiebreaker rules in NC Thu, 10 October 2013 19:48
OK, I may be told that now is not the time to bring this up, but I really think this needs discussed. I remember there being some issues/ concerns/discussions about the Tiebreaker rules in last two NCs. Below is what is written in current rules:

Quote:

14.2. Tiebreaker in Round Robin
To decide upon rank in the round robin, number of clashes won is the first tiebreaker, then the number of matches won, then the number of games won, then the round robin result between the relevant teams.
To determine the best 2nd team when relevant (i.e. when the number of teams per group is not the same for all groups) :
The results of the last seeded team(s) will be removed from the results in the relevant groups to make all groups even. Tiebreaker as described in 14.2 will then apply.
If the last seeded team in this particular group is in the running for a bye, then the results of the second to last seed will be removed.


Now what I remember is that many people feel that if two teams end up with a tied record, in first, 2nd 3rd, or 4th positions of their grouping, that first tiebreaker should be who won in their direct clash of the round robin.

This would seem to me to be especially important if two teams are tied for 4th as that determines who advances to the KO round. It does not seem right to have a team you directly beat, advance based on a side factor and not the direct competition that occurred. Under current rules the Round Robin result between two teams is the 4th tie-breaker.

How do we address this concern? AND maybe it is not a concern to other teams. Is there a system in place to discuss and vote on this or is it already decided and no way to change for this year.
      

ThemaVerfasserDatum
  Tiebreaker rules in NC  onyx puffin LOLThu, 10 October 2013 19:48
  Re:Tiebreaker rules in NC DrakeStormThu, 10 October 2013 21:41
  Re:Tiebreaker rules in NC onyx puffin LOLThu, 10 October 2013 22:23
  Re:Tiebreaker rules in NC DrakeStormThu, 10 October 2013 23:25
  Re:Tiebreaker rules in NC dea1Fri, 11 October 2013 00:18
  Re:Tiebreaker rules in NC BAM Vballman20Fri, 11 October 2013 01:53
  Re:Tiebreaker rules in NC QorlasFri, 11 October 2013 02:13
  Re:Tiebreaker rules in NC SysyphusFri, 11 October 2013 02:46
  Re:Tiebreaker rules in NC onyx puffin LOLFri, 11 October 2013 14:33
  Re:Tiebreaker rules in NC DrakeStormFri, 11 October 2013 02:45
  Re:Tiebreaker rules in NC QorlasFri, 11 October 2013 03:03
  Re:Tiebreaker rules in NC DrakeStormFri, 11 October 2013 03:16
  Re:Tiebreaker rules in NC QorlasFri, 11 October 2013 14:23
  Re:Tiebreaker rules in NC QorlasFri, 11 October 2013 14:53
Vorheriges Thema:NC Italia
Nächstes Thema:NC TD Ruling
Gehen Sie zum Forum: