Ticket to Ride New York Ticket to Ride New York


Forums » Memoir '44 - English » Battles review is insufficiency !!
Show: Today's Posts 
Junior Member

User Pages
Posts: 4
March 2014
Battles review is insufficiency !! Sat, 06 June 2015 15:06
What is the point of review battles, if only two or three stars are possible??
There is no one star reviews at all ??

Player 1548666
Senior Member

User Pages
Posts: 1961
November 2007
Re:Battles review is insufficiency !! Sun, 07 June 2015 08:55
You can reward one star for a scenario, but the review score is an average for all reviews.

I guess too many people give out two and three star reviews for there to be one star reviews in the tables.
Senior Member
Lieutenant Colonel

User Pages
Posts: 779
May 2008
Re:Battles review is insufficiency !! Sun, 07 June 2015 10:02
My online scenario The battle of la Roche has 51 Ratings so far.
33 have 3 stars.
16 have 2 stars.
2 have 1 star.
On average it scores 2,6.
It has only 6 AAR after action reports.

Playing for some time now i think the following.

People that know you, tend to give you maybe 3 stars easyer then people you never played, although i see names of people i never played amongst those 3 stars.

People that lose big maybe tend to give a 1 star because they blame the scenario lol.

I never made action reports here or on vassal, i know lots that do so and even write them very detailed.

Conclusion it would be great to know why someone gives you 1 star and others just feel its 2 or 3 stars.
I guess we all have are favourites and sometimes people don't like one sided scenario's.

Personally i like to play many diffrent ones and as long as you can play both sides, i even like one sided scenario's.

[Updated on: Sun, 07 June 2015 10:03]

Previous Topic:Summary cards?
Next Topic:HELP -Tournament 8 player / 4 scenario game schedule
Goto Forum: